3D scanning solution brought in to beat the heat on challenging fuel pipe demolition and replacement project
Acensium is an engineering consulting services firm with a focus on material handling retrofit projects and 3D scanning for as-built reality capture.
SPONSORED CONTENT | BIM AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY | AUGUST 28, 2017 | JASON SCHWARTZ, PRINCIPAL AT ACENSIUM
3D model of project shown in Navisworks, models developed in Cyclone and Revit.
Plant Bowen, a coal-fired power station owned by Georgia Power Company in Euharlee, Ga., needed to undergo an ambitious demolition and replacement of its Unit-4 fuel pipe. Coal dust, which is the consistency of talcum powder, is blown through the fuel pipe from the pulverizer for ignition. In order to tackle the challenging and inherently dangerous project, Georgia Power called upon Acensium to provide engineering support and take on the piping digitization to support demolition and installation/construction teams (Contractor: Zachary; Fabrication: JMS). Among the main issues the project faced was that the fuel pipe was confined by structural members, floor members, plant equipment, and the boiler itself with little clearance to perform the work. The looming question was how to remove the old pipe from the building and get the new pipe installed.
Acensium is an engineering consulting services firm with a focus on material handling retrofit projects and 3D scanning for as-built reality capture, originally founded in 2003 in Denver, Colorado. The team was able to successfully assess the difficult project and plot a course of action by tapping into its expertise providing engineering and intellectual services, operations, consulting and engineering support primarily for the power, steel and paper industries throughout the United States.
Cross section of single pulverizer outlet. FARO point cloud in Recap using the intensity filter.
The multi-million dollar project—the demolition and replacement of the #4 fuel pipe—included millions of dollars in erected scaffolding alone, as well as a 141-man crew, 7-day-a-week work schedule and 35 days of plant “outage time” to do the work within. Plans specified a completion timeframe of one year from the planning stage.
What made this project particularly challenging was that it necessitated working next to a boiler with an ambient temperature of 120 degrees F. The facility was built around the equipment so everything was a tight fit.
Furthermore, this was a high-heat/high-hazard environment with high noise levels and large amounts of vibration in addition to the huge volume to scans. The complex project required specialized safety training, insurance requirements and background checks as it was not a standard industrial environment, including the need for scans to be taken just feet from a boiler with an internal temperature of over 1500 degrees F.
As a result of recent successes on multimillion dollar projects and digital visualization for Georgia Power, plant management requested Acensium’s involvement during the planning phase. Acensium demonstrated what would be able to be done with example scans to illustrate for project leads what was possible. Georgia Power recognized that the project could not be accomplished without 3D scanning project control and so Acensium utilized the FARO® Focus Laser Scanners and SCENE Software.
Had more traditional methods been used instead, the process would have included arduous and time-consuming tasks of measurements, estimation and guesswork to determine what changes had been made since the original design from decades ago. As a typical project team cannot simply look at 2D as-built drawings and understand the full scope of what is going on, the use of 3D scanning gives insight to the whole team. With a building constructed around the equipment, clearances are at a minimum. Understanding the operation and arrangement of every pipe and support was crucial for project success.
With a facility that has been literally built around installed power plant equipment in 1975, everything had to be mapped for success. There were no clearances designed-in for removal or addition of components as you would see in a facility built before equipment is installed. Every support beam, pipe, bracket and bolt needed to be accounted for to ensure that components can come out of (and into) the facility as needed. For example, a 50-foot pipe may need to be replaced in 10-foot sections instead of the original 50-foot solid length. There may simply be no way to get 50 feet of pipe into the building if not sectioned out. To that end, FARO 3D scanning technology, coupled with a highly skilled team, was paramount.
Jason Adkins, Principal at Acensium, says, “The skills and experience of personnel is key. You have to have great equipment, but behind that equipment is an engineering mind. To be able to provide engineering consulting and support effectively on jobs like this, it takes a high-level industry expert. The 3D scanning, modeling and visualization then allows you to communicate that expertise to every project stakeholder.”
Hoist rail beam spacing shown in Navisworks, models developed in Cyclone and Revit.
Dynamic visualization was used to show parts moving in and out of the constricted project area. The modeling was a mix of clash detection and project process planning. Visualization was also used to enhance communication between project stakeholders.
It should be noted that Acensium was called in late in the process. Typically, Acensium is present from day one of planning. Scans started only 48 hours before the scaffolding build-out began. The scanning had to be completed before the scaffolding blocked key viewpoint angles. Acensium’s team worked around the clock to get the initial as-built scanning done. Modeling and visualization support throughout demolition and installation processes allowed the team to account for unforeseen issues. Additional scans of specific areas can be taken, if needed, to resolve an issue.
FARO Focus hardware and settings dealt with constant high vibrations. Care had to be taken in a high-heat environment with human exposure-time. FARO equipment operated for hours in a high-heat environment at 120 degrees F to produce key scans.
Final deliverables included model point-cloud overlay, engineering support and project control throughout the project — planning through completion.
Time and Costs Savings
While it is nearly impossible to measure exactly the time saved, it can safely be stated that if modeling had not been performed, many unforeseen issues would have occurred. For instance, it takes 22 man-hours to weld one joint. Rigging a pipe to be picked up takes 12 man-hours. If done incorrectly, it has to be disconnected and another pipe rigged. Easily, 1500+ man-hours were saved in avoided risk. Without visualization, 20% cost overruns would not be unheard of.
Since 2009, Acensium has had numerous projects through Georgia Power, including six prior laser-scanning-based coal-handling projects at Bowen plant. As a testament to the client’s satisfaction with the work completed, recurring business through Bowen is expected to continue, with new projects currently in the works.
For more information, visit www.acensium.com.
Our site has been updated.
If you already have an account, please register again.